← Methodology
Production · Metric

Trade-Rule Authorship

trade-rule-authorship

Definition

trade-rule-authorship measures structural power over the terms on which production is exchanged — who writes or blocks the rules of the trading system, whose agreement templates others adopt, and who can deny market access. The structural question is: who sets the terms of global trade? — not who has the largest trade share. This metric serves Strange's "on what terms" clause, applied to exchange.

Strange's grounding

The trading system is a Strange secondary structure (Strange 1994, p.139), folded into Production because its rule-setting content governs "on what terms" production circulates:

  • "what is produced, by whom and for whom, by what method and on what terms" (Strange 1994, p.64)
  • rule-laying as structural power: "[laying] down legal and administrative processes and precedents that make it hard for others to challenge or upset" (Strange 1994, p.29)
  • the denial lever: "whoever is able to develop or acquire and to deny the access of others to a kind of knowledge respected and sought by others… will exercise a very special kind of structural power" (Strange 1994, p.30) — instantiated by market-access denial.

Share of trade is sheer mass — "something to sell which other people badly want" is economic, not structural, power (Strange 1994, p.25); paying a large WTO budget buys no agenda. The structural lever is who writes the rules. Strange's own warning underwrites the fold: the trading system and the other named secondary structures are "secondary to the four primary structures of security, production, finance and knowledge, which play a large part in shaping the secondary structures" (Strange 1994, p.139) — so trade rules are read through the production structure that shapes them.

Components

ComponentStructural question it answersCitable source
Rule-writing agenda powerWho sets or blocks the terms of multilateral trade rules?WTO negotiation records; dispute-settlement leadership
RTA template authorshipWhose agreement template do others adopt?RTA text-provenance analysis; WTO RTA database
Market-access denial capabilityWho can deny others access to markets and dictate terms?Tariff/trade-defence & market-access-restriction records

Scores across the twelve

US 95.0 China 63.7 Japan 57.0 Germany 46.3 France 42.7 UK 42.7 Italy 40.0 Canada 39.0 India 30.3 Brazil 18.0 Russia 12.7 South Africa 12.7

Normalized component-mean for this metric, 0–95. Click a nation for its full breakdown.